Customer Journeys That Build Loyalty: Start Simple, Scale Smart - Part 3

Welcome to Part 3 of our series on customer journeys that build loyalty. In Part 1, we explored how restaurants lose €422,400 annually to platform dependency and introduced the three-phase framework. In Part 2, we covered how automated journeys work. Now, let’s get tactical: which journeys to build, in what order, and for which customer segments.

This is where strategy meets execution. The restaurants that win don’t try to do everything at oncethey start with one powerful journey, prove the economics, then expand systematically.

The Foundation: Your First Journey

Start here: Post-Dining Thank You + Strategic Incentive

Why This Journey First?

Immediate ROI - You’re capturing customers at peak satisfaction, when they’re most receptive.

Proven conversion rates - 40-50% engagement, 20-30% complete the desired action.

Simple to execute - Single trigger (visit completion), clear goal (return visit), measurable outcome (redemption).

Establishes the pattern - Trains customers to expect personalized communication from you, not just platforms.

The Business Mechanics

Trigger: Customer completes first visit with 4-5 star satisfaction

Message: Personalized thank you + non-monetary gift (e.g., complimentary dessert)

Redemption Rules:

• Valid 14 days (urgency)
• Lunch only (fill slow periods)
• Automatically enforced (no staff training needed)

Economics:

• Gift cost: €3
• Average return visit revenue: €27
• Net profit: €14
• Platform commission saved: €3.00
• Total value per converted customer: €17.00

With 2,000 monthly first-timers and 45% redemption rate:

• 900 redemptions
• 900 × €17.00 = €15,300 monthly profit
• €183,600 annual impact from this single journey

This is your proof of concept. Once this runs smoothly, expand.

The Strategic Expansion Framework

Don’t add journeys randomly. Each serves a specific business objective and customer segment.

Journey 2: VIP Recognition & Retention

Business objective: Protect and grow your most valuable customers

Segment: Customers with 5+ visits in 3 months or €500+ lifetime spend

Why this next: Your top 20% of customers generate 60-80% of revenue. A 5% increase in VIP retention is worth more than acquiring 50 new customers.

The Journey:

Trigger: Customer crosses VIP threshold

Immediate: VIP status notification

• “You’re now a valued VIP member”
• Exclusive benefits reveal
• Personal recognition from owner/chef

Ongoing: Monthly exclusive previews

• New menu items first access
• Chef’s table invitations
• Private event announcements

Birthday: Special celebration offer

• Complimentary champagne
• Reserved best table
• Personalized dessert

If inactive 30 days: Personal outreach

• “We miss you” message
• Exclusive return incentive
• Direct line to reservations manager

Business Impact:

• VIP visit frequency: +130% (from 1x to 2.3x per month)
• Average spend per visit: +40%
• Lifetime value: +175%
• Word-of-mouth referrals: 4.2 per VIP annually

Journey 3: Win-Back Inactive Customers

Business objective: Recapture lost revenue from dormant customers

Segment: Customers who haven’t visited in 60+ days (previously visited 2+ times)

Why this matters: You already invested in acquiring them. They know your restaurant. Reactivation costs 5x less than new acquisition.

The Journey:

Day 60: Friendly reminder

• “It’s been a while…”
• What’s new at the restaurant
• Soft invitation to return

Day 75: Value offer

• Time-limited incentive (€10 off, free appetizer)
• Emphasize what they’re missing
• Create urgency (offer expires in 7 days)

Day 85: Last chance

• Final reminder
• Stronger incentive for immediate booking
• Personal touch (owner signature)

If they return: Welcome back sequence

• Acknowledge the gap
• Reinforce why they came back
• Get them on regular cadence

Business Impact:

• Reactivation rate: 15-20% of dormant customers
• For 400 monthly dormant customers: 60-80 reactivations
• Average reactivated customer lifetime value: €320
• Monthly value: €19,200-€25,600

Journey 4: Birthday & Anniversary Campaigns

Business objective: Capture high-value celebratory dining occasions

Segment: Customers with known birthdays or dining anniversaries

Why this works: People spend 60% more on celebration meals. They’re planning to dine out regardlessyou’re ensuring it’s at your restaurant, not a competitor’s.

The Journey:

30 days before: Early announcement

• “Your birthday is coming up!”
• Special menu preview
• Early booking incentive

14 days before: Booking reminder

• Limited availability messaging
• Specific offer (free dessert, champagne, etc.)
• Easy one-click reservation

Day of (if booked): Preparation

• Staff briefed on celebration
• Table preparation
• Special touches ready

Day after: Thank you + future hook

• Personalized appreciation
• Photos from the evening (if taken)
• Anniversary gift card (valid in 12 months)

Business Impact:

• Capture rate: 35% of birthdays in database
• Average celebration spending: €180 vs. €30 regular
• Anniversary return rate: 42%
• Creates annual recurring event

Journey 5: Slow Period Activation

Business objective: Fill unused capacity during off-peak times

Segment: Customers within 3km radius, available during target period

Why this matters: Empty tables generate zero revenue. Every filled seat during slow periods is pure margin.

The Journey (Example: Tuesday Lunch)

Monday 10am: Initial offer

• “Special Tuesday lunch offer just for nearby guests”
• Limited-time menu or discount
• Geographic targeting (nearby offices, residents)

Monday 5pm: Reminder to openers

• “Don’t forget - tomorrow’s special lunch”
• Booking link front and center
• Time-sensitive (lunch slots filling up)

Tuesday 9am: Last call

• Push notification or SMS
• “Last chance - a few tables left”
• Immediate booking option

Tuesday 2pm (if attended): Thank you

• Appreciation message
• Invitation to make it a weekly tradition
• “Same time next week?” with easy booking

Business Impact:

• Off-peak covers increase: 25-35%
• Incremental weekly revenue: €2,400-€3,360
• Annual impact: €124,800-€174,720
• Builds habitual behavior (recurring Tuesdays)

Journey 6: Holiday & Event Campaigns

Business objective: Maximize revenue during high-demand periods

Segment: Entire customer base, segmented by past holiday dining behavior

Why strategic timing matters: Valentine’s Day, Mother’s Day, NYEthese are guaranteed dining-out occasions. You’re competing for the booking, not convincing them to dine out.

The Journey (Example: Valentine’s Day)

45 days before: Early bird announcement

• “Valentine’s reservations now open”
• Special menu preview
• Early booking bonus (free champagne)

30 days before: First reminder

• To those who haven’t booked
• Emphasize limited availability
• Show what they’re missing (past years’ photos)

14 days before: Urgency messaging

• “Almost fully booked”
• Waitlist option if needed
• Alternative date suggestions

7 days before: Final push

• Last-chance for remaining slots
• Higher urgency tone
• Immediate booking required

Day after event: Future booking capture

• Thank you + experience feedback
• Gift card for next anniversary
• Automatic reminder in 12 months

Business Impact:

• Booking rate: 85% vs. 60% without journey automation
• Average spend: 2.8x regular dining
• Gift card sales: 40% purchase for future use
• Creates annual customer cycle

The Compounding Effect

Here’s what most restaurants miss: these journeys work together.

A customer who:

1. Receives post-dining thank you (Journey 1)
2. Becomes a VIP after 5 visits (Journey 2)
3. Gets birthday recognition (Journey 4)
4. Receives Valentine’s Day invitation (Journey 6)

…has received 4+ personalized touchpoints, creating a relationship impossible to replicate on booking platforms.

Customer lifetime value comparison:

Platform-only customer:

• Average visits per year: 2.1
• Average spend per visit: €30
• Annual value: €63
• Platform commissions: €10.92
• Heavy discounting: -€31.50
• Net annual value: €20.58

Journey-nurtured customer:

• Average visits per year: 8.4
• Average spend per visit: €35
• Annual value: €294
• Platform commissions: €3.00 (first visit only)
• Strategic incentives: -€24
• Net annual value: €267.00

Difference: €246.42 per customer annually

For a restaurant with 1,000 active customers:

• Additional annual profit: €246,420

Implementation Sequence: Your 90-Day Roadmap

Month 1: Foundation

• Week 1-2: Set up post-dining thank you journey
• Week 3: Monitor and optimize
• Week 4: Prove ROI and get team buy-in

Month 2: Expansion

• Week 5-6: Add VIP recognition journey
• Week 7: Launch win-back journey
• Week 8: Measure combined impact

Month 3: Optimization

• Week 9-10: Add birthday/anniversary journeys
• Week 11: Implement slow-period activation
• Week 12: Plan holiday campaigns

By day 90, you have 5-6 journeys running automatically, each targeting specific segments with specific objectives.

The Strategic Principles

1. One journey at a time - Prove it works before adding complexity.

2. Segment ruthlessly - VIPs, regulars, first-timers, and inactive customers need different approaches.

3. Measure everything - Track enrollment, engagement, conversion, and revenue per journey.

4. Start with high-ROI journeys - Post-dining and VIP recognition pay back immediately.

5. Build habits, not transactions - Tuesday lunch regulars, annual birthday dinners, monthly VIP perks.

6. Let them compound - Each journey reinforces the others, creating a relationship ecosystem.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Starting with too many journeys - Overwhelming your team and diluting focus. Start with one, nail it, expand.

Generic messaging - “Dear customer” doesn’t work. Use their name, reference their preferences, acknowledge their history.

Ignoring timing - Monday morning 6am emails get deleted. Tuesday 10am for lunch offers works.

Over-discounting - You’re not competing on price. Strategic gifts (free dessert) create more loyalty than 20% off.

No clear goal - Every journey needs one primary objective: book a table, redeem a gift, leave a review.

---

Ready to see the results in action?

In Part 4 of this series, we’ll explore:

• The 6-month transformation timeline with detailed month-by-month results
• Technology capabilities that make automated journeys possible
• Customer psychology: why automated journeys build genuine loyalty
• Strategic advantages beyond cost savings

The truth: Your competitors are already running these journeys. Every week you wait, you’re losing customers to restaurants that remember birthdays, recognize VIPs, and create personal connections.

Book a Free Demo → See how these journeys come to life with automated systems that handle the complexity while you reap the rewards.