Customer Journeys That Build Loyalty: From €5,200 Monthly Losses to Profitable Direct Relationships - Part 1

Picture this: A bustling restaurant serving 4,000 covers monthly. Half their customers discover them through TheFork, attracted by 50% off promotions. The restaurant pays €2.60 per customer in commissions€5,200 every monthplus absorbs massive revenue losses from the deep discounts. Margins evaporate, brand value erodes, and the restaurant becomes trapped in an endless cycle of discounting to survive. Sound familiar? Here’s how smart restaurants are engineering customer journeys that break this cycle, build genuine loyalty, and reclaim profitability.

The Math That Keeps Restaurant Owners Awake

Let’s examine the real economics of platform dependency:

The Traditional TheFork Model: Death by a Thousand Cuts

Monthly Reality:

• Total monthly covers: 4,000
• Covers from TheFork (50%): 2,000
• Commission at €3.00 per customer: €6,000/month
• Average ticket per person: €30
• 50% discount applied: -€15 per customer
• Monthly revenue loss from discounts: €30,000

Annual Impact:

• Commission fees: €72,000
• Revenue loss from discounts: €360,000
• Total annual cost: €432,000

For most mid-sized restaurants, this represents nearly 20% of annual revenue simply vanishing to maintain platform presence. But the financial damage is only part of the story.

The Hidden Costs No One Talks About

1. Margin Destruction

When you’re operating on typical restaurant margins of 10-15% and giving away half your revenue on 50% of covers, the math becomes devastating:

• Gross margin on full-price customer: 65%
• Gross margin on 50% discount customer: 15%
• Net margin after commission: 5-7% (if you’re lucky)

You’re working harder, serving more customers, and earning less. There’s no capital for growth, team development, or weathering economic downturns.

2. Brand Value Erosion

When customers only know you as “that place with 50% off,” you’ve lost control of your brand positioning:

• Customer perception: “Not worth full price”
• Competitive differentiation: None (everyone’s discounting)
• Pricing power: Zero
• Customer loyalty: Purely transactional

The discount becomes your identity, not your food, service, or atmosphere.

3. The Repeat Customer Trap

The cruelest irony: Your best customers cost you the most.

Every time a regular books through TheFork:

• You pay €3+ commission (again)
• You offer 50% off (again)
• You have no direct relationship (still)
• TheFork owns the customer data (forever)

You’re essentially paying rent on relationships you already built.

Why This Cycle Continues: The Platform Lock-In Effect

If this is so clearly unsustainable, why do thousands of restaurants accept it? Because TheFork engineers dependency:

Discovery Monopoly: They control access to customers actively searching for restaurants.

Convenience Trap: Customer payment info, preferences, and YUMs points live on the platform.

Data Asymmetry: While you can technically access customer data, you lack systems to act on it effectively.

Review Hostage: Your TheFork rating affects visibility, creating fear around reducing platform presence.

Operational Inertia: Staff rely on their system; change feels complicated and risky.

The result? Restaurants become permanent tenants in someone else’s customer ecosystem.

The Customer Journey Revolution: Taking Back Control

Here’s the strategic insight that changes everything: You don’t need to abandon booking platformsyou need to stop letting them own your customers forever.

The new model isn’t about choosing between platform visibility and profitability. It’s about engineering intentional customer journeys that transform one-time platform bookings into lasting direct relationships.

The Three-Phase Journey Framework

Phase 1: Smart Discovery Use TheFork for its intended purposeintroducing new customers to your restaurantbut on terms that don’t destroy your economics.

Phase 2: Intelligent Conversion Automatically capture first-time visitors and give them compelling reasons to return directly.

Phase 3: Loyalty Engineering Deploy strategic incentives with smart timing and redemption rules that drive desired behaviors and build genuine loyalty.

This is where technology transforms everything. Manual customer relationship management doesn’t scale. Automated, intelligent systems do.

Enter Caramel: Customer Journeys That Work

Let’s walk through how this plays out in practice using the Caramel platform:

Step 1: Reduce the Discovery Discount (50% ’ 30%)

You maintain TheFork visibility but stop hemorrhaging revenue:

Previous Economics:

• Average ticket: €30
• 50% discount: -€15
• Commission: €3.00
• Total first-visit cost: €18.00

New Economics:

• Average ticket: €30
• 30% discount: -€9
• Commission: €3.00
• Total first-visit cost: €12.00
• Savings per customer: €6.00

For 2,000 monthly TheFork customers: €12,000 monthly savings immediately

You’re still attractive on the platform30% off is meaningfulbut you’re not destroying your margins.

Step 2: Automated Customer Capture & Engagement

The moment a customer completes their first visit, Caramel’s intelligent system activates:

Automatic TheFork Integration

• Pulls reservation data in real-time
• Identifies first-time vs. repeat customers
• Captures complete contact information
• Updates unified customer database

Personalized Thank-You Sequence

• Sends tailored message acknowledging their visit
• References specific details (party size, celebration, etc.)
• Builds immediate personal connection
• Sets the stage for ongoing relationship

No manual work. No staff training required. Just seamless automation.

Step 3: Strategic Incentive with Smart Redemption Rules

Here’s where customer journey engineering becomes powerful. Instead of generic “10% off next visit,” you deploy strategic incentives designed to drive specific behaviors:

The Offer: Complimentary Dessert

• Non-monetary gift card issued automatically
• Instantly delivered to customer’s Apple Wallet or Google Wallet
• Direct booking link embedded in the gift card itself
• Clear directives to book via your own booking platform or Google (free on TheFork)
• Perceived value: €8-12
• Actual cost to you: €3
• Emotional impact: High (feels special, not transactional)

The Intelligence: Redemption Engineering

This isn’t just a free dessert anytime. It’s strategically designed:

Time-Limited Urgency (2-Week Validity)

• Creates immediate reason to return
• Prevents indefinite procrastination
• Drives near-term traffic when memory is fresh
• Establishes return visit pattern

Daypart Targeting (Lunch Only)

• Fills your slowest service period
• Maximizes incremental revenue potential
• Balances capacity utilization
• Doesn’t cannibalize high-demand dinner slots

Automated Enforcement

• Caramel validates redemption rules automatically
• No staff confusion or redemption errors
• No training required
• No fraud or abuse

The system handles everything: issuance, customer notification, redemption validation, and tracking.

Step 4: Capture the Incremental Value

When that customer returns for their complimentary dessert:

Customer Economics:

• Main course purchase (lunch average): €22
• Dessert (your cost): €3
• Beverage (typical): €5
• Total customer spend: €27

Your Economics:

• Revenue: €27
• Food/beverage cost: €10
• Gross profit: €17
• Dessert cost: €3
• Net incremental profit: €14
• No commission: €0
• No discount: €0

You’ve converted a platform-dependent customer to a direct relationship for €3 in dessert cost while generating €14 in incremental profit.

Comparison to TheFork Repeat Visit:

• Previous cost (50% discount + commission): €17.60 loss
• New cost (free dessert): €3 cost, €14 profit
• Swing per customer: €31.60

---

Ready to see the complete transformation in action?

In Part 2 of this series, we’ll explore:

• The compound effect: Six-month transformation with detailed month-by-month numbers
• The technology foundation: Caramel platform capabilities that make it all automatic
• Customer psychology: Why customers switch and how to engineer it
• Strategic advantages: Beyond savings, the real benefits of owning your relationships
• Implementation roadmap: How to start and scale your direct booking system

The fundamental truth: You’re already doing the hard work of creating exceptional dining experiences. You’re just paying someone else to own the relationship with your customers. That changes today.

Continue to Part 2 →